Designated Survivor: Season 1, Episode 10 “The Oath” (C)
This show has firmly decided what it wants to be, and there were multiple times during this episode that I heard music that I could have sworn was originally featured on “24” (or just very similar to it). This isn’t a show about a man who assumed the presidency without qualifications; instead, it’s the kind of thriller that has the first person coming to the scene of a vicious car crash there to try to suffocate the survivor to make sure that she can’t get away and talk. Fortunately, Hannah is just the kind of Jack Bauer-type agent that she, even in her bloody, concussion-created delirium was alert enough to put her food on the gas and escape her would-be killer. Unfortunately, she didn’t think to grab the evidence while she was at it. That said, we now know that it wasn’t actually MacLeish at the helm of everything but his wife. As the episode came to a close, we got to the point where it became clear what was happening, that Tom was going to be assassinated by a conveniently-placed gunman just after MacLeish was officially sworn in as his number-two and eligible to ascend to the presidency. Hannah was at least smart enough to figure out how to divert attention to her and hopefully make the gunman miss, since Kiefer Sutherland not being on this show is an impossibility given its marketing. Top advisors kissing and journalists lying doesn’t cut it as subplots for me, so I’m hoping for a more resilient and believable direction when this show returns in March.
Showing posts with label Designated Survivor. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Designated Survivor. Show all posts
Tuesday, January 3, 2017
Monday, December 19, 2016
What I’m Watching: Designated Survivor
Designated Survivor: Season 1, Episode 9 “The Blueprint” (C)
It seems inevitable that a whistleblower would have showed up on this show, as if there weren’t enough high-profile secrets that are way too out in the open to be remotely believable. The fact that someone could leak something incriminating to get Tom to seriously consider firing Emily but withhold important evidence that proved every single allegation that she had cited seems far too convenient and totally out of the realm of control. At least Tom has smart people by his side, with Aaron, Emily, and Seth all watching out for him in different ways. Aaron realizing what the whistleblower wanted and helping to make it all go away was very useful, and it’s good to see that he’s firmly on the president’s side now. On the far more action-oriented side of things, we were introduced to Reed Diamond’s director of Internal Affairs, who should be smart enough to realize that Jason is the victim of a frame job. Instead, Hannah is out in the wind all by herself, discovering such things as Catalan being in MacLeish’s unit where all of his men say exactly the same thing about his heroism. Calling Kimble was a smart move, but driving like a maniac only to be hit quite deliberately by a car en route didn’t help her cause much. This is the kind of thing that was worth discussing on the phone just to make sure she didn’t get killed first. Now that she is likely out of the picture, we’re treated to such thrills as Tom taking off his glasses to show just how precarious his situation is with a traitor in his government.
It seems inevitable that a whistleblower would have showed up on this show, as if there weren’t enough high-profile secrets that are way too out in the open to be remotely believable. The fact that someone could leak something incriminating to get Tom to seriously consider firing Emily but withhold important evidence that proved every single allegation that she had cited seems far too convenient and totally out of the realm of control. At least Tom has smart people by his side, with Aaron, Emily, and Seth all watching out for him in different ways. Aaron realizing what the whistleblower wanted and helping to make it all go away was very useful, and it’s good to see that he’s firmly on the president’s side now. On the far more action-oriented side of things, we were introduced to Reed Diamond’s director of Internal Affairs, who should be smart enough to realize that Jason is the victim of a frame job. Instead, Hannah is out in the wind all by herself, discovering such things as Catalan being in MacLeish’s unit where all of his men say exactly the same thing about his heroism. Calling Kimble was a smart move, but driving like a maniac only to be hit quite deliberately by a car en route didn’t help her cause much. This is the kind of thing that was worth discussing on the phone just to make sure she didn’t get killed first. Now that she is likely out of the picture, we’re treated to such thrills as Tom taking off his glasses to show just how precarious his situation is with a traitor in his government.
Thursday, December 15, 2016
What I’m Watching: Designated Survivor
Designated Survivor: Season 1, Episode 8 “The Results” (C)
I feel like I haven’t seen this show in a month, and that’s mainly because I’m so behind on TV and no episode aired during Thanksgiving Week. I almost forgot that it was on and missed it altogether, and I’m not so sure that would be a bad thing. At this point, two more episodes have already aired and the show is on hiatus until March, so it’s probably worth catching up. The problem is that this show is not turning into what I had hoped it would be, and instead it’s failing on pretty much all fronts. Jason being blackmailed is by far the worst thread, and I can’t imagine how he thought that confessing to killing Nassar was going to play out well for him and assure that his son will be released. And on their side, where did they expect this to go? For whatever reason, Hannah is being encouraged by her own Deep Throat not to talk, and now he’s in custody but no one believes that he’s actually guilty. Everyone loves a cryptic clue-giver, and looking into 11:14pm is sure to take Hannah at least a few episodes. Tom is much more preoccupied with other things, namely going to vote to show the American public that it was safe to do so and trying to maintain his relationship with the son who might not actually be his (though he is). And of course Lisa’s total betrayal of Seth is merely a signal of the power of democracy. I’m not impressed.
I feel like I haven’t seen this show in a month, and that’s mainly because I’m so behind on TV and no episode aired during Thanksgiving Week. I almost forgot that it was on and missed it altogether, and I’m not so sure that would be a bad thing. At this point, two more episodes have already aired and the show is on hiatus until March, so it’s probably worth catching up. The problem is that this show is not turning into what I had hoped it would be, and instead it’s failing on pretty much all fronts. Jason being blackmailed is by far the worst thread, and I can’t imagine how he thought that confessing to killing Nassar was going to play out well for him and assure that his son will be released. And on their side, where did they expect this to go? For whatever reason, Hannah is being encouraged by her own Deep Throat not to talk, and now he’s in custody but no one believes that he’s actually guilty. Everyone loves a cryptic clue-giver, and looking into 11:14pm is sure to take Hannah at least a few episodes. Tom is much more preoccupied with other things, namely going to vote to show the American public that it was safe to do so and trying to maintain his relationship with the son who might not actually be his (though he is). And of course Lisa’s total betrayal of Seth is merely a signal of the power of democracy. I’m not impressed.
Tuesday, November 22, 2016
What I’m Watching: Designated Survivor
Designated Survivor: Season 1, Episode 7 “The Traitor” (C+)
I’ve written a lot recently about what kind of show this series wants to be, and I think I’m getting my answer. I liked the excitement that Tom felt when he was able to successfully execute Emily’s plan to turn a very bad situation with an American CIA informant under arrest in Russia into a three-way trade that would benefit all countries involved. That he turned out to be a converted Russian double agent was a disappointment, especially since that information was so easily and immediately accessible after he didn’t disembark the plane. More problematic and disappointing, however, was the bombshell development at the end of the episode where it was confirmed that Jason’s son wasn’t just lost but was in fact being held hostage by nefarious criminals who have already declared their intention to have Jason give a message to the president when he meets privately with him. Tom has enough to worry about without having to contend with people actually spying on him and manipulating his moves through the deputy director of the FBI and the leverage they have against him. We already know that Tom doesn’t like Jason, so let’s hope that he’s able to sense that something is wrong when they meet. MacLeish being so ominous will probably pan out as a red herring, but for now it’s a disconcerting distraction. This Myers business doesn’t seem to be going away, and Alex now knows what it is that he wants, something that Tom definitely shouldn’t grant him unless he wants to lose all credibility.
I’ve written a lot recently about what kind of show this series wants to be, and I think I’m getting my answer. I liked the excitement that Tom felt when he was able to successfully execute Emily’s plan to turn a very bad situation with an American CIA informant under arrest in Russia into a three-way trade that would benefit all countries involved. That he turned out to be a converted Russian double agent was a disappointment, especially since that information was so easily and immediately accessible after he didn’t disembark the plane. More problematic and disappointing, however, was the bombshell development at the end of the episode where it was confirmed that Jason’s son wasn’t just lost but was in fact being held hostage by nefarious criminals who have already declared their intention to have Jason give a message to the president when he meets privately with him. Tom has enough to worry about without having to contend with people actually spying on him and manipulating his moves through the deputy director of the FBI and the leverage they have against him. We already know that Tom doesn’t like Jason, so let’s hope that he’s able to sense that something is wrong when they meet. MacLeish being so ominous will probably pan out as a red herring, but for now it’s a disconcerting distraction. This Myers business doesn’t seem to be going away, and Alex now knows what it is that he wants, something that Tom definitely shouldn’t grant him unless he wants to lose all credibility.
Thursday, November 17, 2016
What I’m Watching: Designated Survivor
Designated Survivor: Season 1, Episode 6 “The Interrogation” (B-)
I was talking to someone about this show and she referred to it as “the new 24.” I’ve always felt that it was this show’s biggest Achilles’ heel, since trying too hard to be an action thriller detracts from it being its own unique political drama. This episode united both genres with the arrival of Nasar on American soil, and I wasn’t too impressed by either direction. The interrogation that Jason and Hannah were conducting felt rather run-of-the-mill, and it didn’t take long for them to come out with some leverage that made this internationally-known, low-grade terrorist give up all the information he had. Hannah’s shock at there not being any hits in the database sounded especially whiny, and it seems that Jason and Hannah’s lives aren’t in jeopardy but Nasar wasn’t long for this world. The gunfire during the gala was a huge disruption to Tom’s call for unification, but there’s still plenty of discord and lack of support for Tom’s presidency. Alex’s involvement in this Syrian refugee plane issue complicated things considerably, and Tom managed to win over the governors with a decision that made Alex lose some respect for him. If Canada can just accept the refugees, isn’t the problem partially solved? This show doesn’t seem to have any true stakes, and Mike getting shot but then being fine demonstrates that this show isn’t so willing to really include major twists that have an impact. I think this show could do well without too many twists in general, but I think that it’s still figuring out exactly what kind of series it wants to be, a journey that’s going okay.
I was talking to someone about this show and she referred to it as “the new 24.” I’ve always felt that it was this show’s biggest Achilles’ heel, since trying too hard to be an action thriller detracts from it being its own unique political drama. This episode united both genres with the arrival of Nasar on American soil, and I wasn’t too impressed by either direction. The interrogation that Jason and Hannah were conducting felt rather run-of-the-mill, and it didn’t take long for them to come out with some leverage that made this internationally-known, low-grade terrorist give up all the information he had. Hannah’s shock at there not being any hits in the database sounded especially whiny, and it seems that Jason and Hannah’s lives aren’t in jeopardy but Nasar wasn’t long for this world. The gunfire during the gala was a huge disruption to Tom’s call for unification, but there’s still plenty of discord and lack of support for Tom’s presidency. Alex’s involvement in this Syrian refugee plane issue complicated things considerably, and Tom managed to win over the governors with a decision that made Alex lose some respect for him. If Canada can just accept the refugees, isn’t the problem partially solved? This show doesn’t seem to have any true stakes, and Mike getting shot but then being fine demonstrates that this show isn’t so willing to really include major twists that have an impact. I think this show could do well without too many twists in general, but I think that it’s still figuring out exactly what kind of series it wants to be, a journey that’s going okay.
Wednesday, November 2, 2016
What I’m Watching: Designated Survivor
Designated Survivor: Season 1, Episode 5 “The Mission” (B-)
The test of this show’s durability is going to be living up to the excitement and shock value of the first episode and deciding what kind of series it’s going to be, somewhere between a political drama and an action thriller. I think it’s actually meant not to be the latter, but fans of “24” and its star will expect that this is where this show is going to go and the series will to a degree head in that direction in service of that expectation. This episode was much more action-oriented on all fronts, with Tom supervising the mission to kill the elusive would-be terrorist who we all know wasn’t actually responsible for bombing the Capitol building. Finding out that they waited too long was an initial setback, but then it ended up getting far more intense with Tom supervising the play-by-play and then hearing about a snafu that ended up resulting in a successful operation with one casualty. I’ve been seeing former “Nip/Tuck” star Dylan Walsh around in a few places recently, and I appreciated the casting of Alex Mallari Jr., who plays Four on “Dark Matter” as one of the soldiers in the operation. Jason trusting Hannah and realizing that something sinister is going on could be real, but something tells me that he’s actually one of the bad guys trying to keep her quiet through fear rather than intimidation. Hannah is dialoguing pretty openly with Kimble, and even though we’ve confirmed that Peter was likely in on the bombing, it’s possible that she too is working against the president in more than just a political way. That’s my paranoid conspiracy thriller brain at work, presuming that something worse than a man who served in prison actually being the father of the president’s son is likely afoot.
The test of this show’s durability is going to be living up to the excitement and shock value of the first episode and deciding what kind of series it’s going to be, somewhere between a political drama and an action thriller. I think it’s actually meant not to be the latter, but fans of “24” and its star will expect that this is where this show is going to go and the series will to a degree head in that direction in service of that expectation. This episode was much more action-oriented on all fronts, with Tom supervising the mission to kill the elusive would-be terrorist who we all know wasn’t actually responsible for bombing the Capitol building. Finding out that they waited too long was an initial setback, but then it ended up getting far more intense with Tom supervising the play-by-play and then hearing about a snafu that ended up resulting in a successful operation with one casualty. I’ve been seeing former “Nip/Tuck” star Dylan Walsh around in a few places recently, and I appreciated the casting of Alex Mallari Jr., who plays Four on “Dark Matter” as one of the soldiers in the operation. Jason trusting Hannah and realizing that something sinister is going on could be real, but something tells me that he’s actually one of the bad guys trying to keep her quiet through fear rather than intimidation. Hannah is dialoguing pretty openly with Kimble, and even though we’ve confirmed that Peter was likely in on the bombing, it’s possible that she too is working against the president in more than just a political way. That’s my paranoid conspiracy thriller brain at work, presuming that something worse than a man who served in prison actually being the father of the president’s son is likely afoot.
Tuesday, October 18, 2016
Take Three: Designated Survivor
Designated Survivor: Season 1, Episode 3 “The Confession” (B)
This episode was somewhat more focused than the second episode, ignoring both of the Kirkman children and instead just featuring the new first lady asking for the help of someone who is surely going to ask for a favor in return at a very bad time. What we’ve seen of Congresswoman Hookstraten, who feels the need to constantly remind everyone that she is currently half of Congress, so far is that she always shows up to be helpful and to the right thing in the moment, in a way that shows that she’s making power moves. Granting Alex’s request means that she’s just biding her time to come at the president in a way that’s really going to hurt him. Emily flying to Michigan to witness and safeguard the protest failed, and then Tom’s authoritative federalization of the National Guard tanked too when they wouldn’t acknowledge his authority either. Lying to Emily so that she would bring Royce to him where he could publicly arrest him without being challenged was cunning but also cutthroat, and it’s definitely the move that Aaron would have made but not something that feels like Tom, who made a good point that it doesn’t always feel good to do what needs to be done. Firing General Cochrane was another successful show of power, one made even more emphatic by his eventual authorization of the mission. Hannah is on the right track, but it would be nice if whoever had information about who was behind the attack on the Capitol didn’t insist of being so cryptic.
This episode was somewhat more focused than the second episode, ignoring both of the Kirkman children and instead just featuring the new first lady asking for the help of someone who is surely going to ask for a favor in return at a very bad time. What we’ve seen of Congresswoman Hookstraten, who feels the need to constantly remind everyone that she is currently half of Congress, so far is that she always shows up to be helpful and to the right thing in the moment, in a way that shows that she’s making power moves. Granting Alex’s request means that she’s just biding her time to come at the president in a way that’s really going to hurt him. Emily flying to Michigan to witness and safeguard the protest failed, and then Tom’s authoritative federalization of the National Guard tanked too when they wouldn’t acknowledge his authority either. Lying to Emily so that she would bring Royce to him where he could publicly arrest him without being challenged was cunning but also cutthroat, and it’s definitely the move that Aaron would have made but not something that feels like Tom, who made a good point that it doesn’t always feel good to do what needs to be done. Firing General Cochrane was another successful show of power, one made even more emphatic by his eventual authorization of the mission. Hannah is on the right track, but it would be nice if whoever had information about who was behind the attack on the Capitol didn’t insist of being so cryptic.
Tuesday, October 11, 2016
Take Three: Designated Survivor
Designated Survivor: Season 1, Episode 3 “The Confession” (B)
It was inevitable that Tom being fired the morning before he would become president would come out and that the American people, already not too enamored with their new commander-in-chief, wouldn’t be happy. What Tom showed, however, in the whole ordeal, is that he values honesty more than anything. Being cast aside by his predecessor’s son in favor of the likeliest candidate to replace him, Virginia Madsen’s Kimble Hookstraten, could have led him to be cold and crass when he found out that his relationship with his father wasn’t all he thought it had been. But instead he chose to share an inspiring moment that gave the newfound orphan a positive take on how his father felt about him, which was a relatively selfless act since the boy’s endorsement meant nothing to him once the funeral was over. Tom was smart to choose Aaron as his Chief of Staff because he needs someone smart and conniving, and I sincerely hope that this new file Aaron has created on him is to protect him from the scandals that will eventually get out and not to create them. If he works with Emily to serve Tom steadfastly, they can do great things. Leo’s antics aren’t terribly enticing, and while Natascha McElhone is a strong actress, I’m not sure Tom’s family needs to be so much of the subject of this show. The discovery that the recently discovered living congressman in the rubble got out of his seat and therefore was likely part of the crew that set off the bomb is unsettling, and Hannah better share that news with Jason soon or she’s going to find herself the sole advocate of a dangerous theory.
It was inevitable that Tom being fired the morning before he would become president would come out and that the American people, already not too enamored with their new commander-in-chief, wouldn’t be happy. What Tom showed, however, in the whole ordeal, is that he values honesty more than anything. Being cast aside by his predecessor’s son in favor of the likeliest candidate to replace him, Virginia Madsen’s Kimble Hookstraten, could have led him to be cold and crass when he found out that his relationship with his father wasn’t all he thought it had been. But instead he chose to share an inspiring moment that gave the newfound orphan a positive take on how his father felt about him, which was a relatively selfless act since the boy’s endorsement meant nothing to him once the funeral was over. Tom was smart to choose Aaron as his Chief of Staff because he needs someone smart and conniving, and I sincerely hope that this new file Aaron has created on him is to protect him from the scandals that will eventually get out and not to create them. If he works with Emily to serve Tom steadfastly, they can do great things. Leo’s antics aren’t terribly enticing, and while Natascha McElhone is a strong actress, I’m not sure Tom’s family needs to be so much of the subject of this show. The discovery that the recently discovered living congressman in the rubble got out of his seat and therefore was likely part of the crew that set off the bomb is unsettling, and Hannah better share that news with Jason soon or she’s going to find herself the sole advocate of a dangerous theory.
Tuesday, October 4, 2016
Round Two: Designated Survivor
Designated Survivor: Season 1, Episode 2 “The First Day” (B)
The big test of this show in week two was to see if it could live up to the excitement and hook of the first episode. I think it did in a few ways, namely in chronicling Tom’s struggles to take the reins while not being taken seriously by those who were supposed to be reporting to him and dealing with very problematic consequences of the attack on the American people and their inherent racism and xenophobia. I’m pleased to see that the dimly-lit conspiracy isn’t taking up too much time, and that instead we’re seeing more outright failures of the new president in his disastrous visit to the capitol and then his kindness and commitment to goodness shining through in his incognito return visit. The angling by both of Tom’s new number twos to be his chief of staff feels a bit petty, and I hope that we’ll have other players soon join the team who will spice things up and help to support Tom as he rebuilds his government. Virginia Madsen’s other designated survivor could have been a major villain, but she’s proven thus far to be a great ally, and if Googling Tom is the worst she’s done so far, I think he’s safe for now. I worry that the focus on Tom’s children, particularly his obnoxious son, may prove distracting, and I’d prefer to see his wife get more of a spotlight. Maggie Q’s Agent Watts really is this show’s Jack Bauer, the one agent who knows what’s going on who just doesn’t have the benefit of anyone listening to her.
The big test of this show in week two was to see if it could live up to the excitement and hook of the first episode. I think it did in a few ways, namely in chronicling Tom’s struggles to take the reins while not being taken seriously by those who were supposed to be reporting to him and dealing with very problematic consequences of the attack on the American people and their inherent racism and xenophobia. I’m pleased to see that the dimly-lit conspiracy isn’t taking up too much time, and that instead we’re seeing more outright failures of the new president in his disastrous visit to the capitol and then his kindness and commitment to goodness shining through in his incognito return visit. The angling by both of Tom’s new number twos to be his chief of staff feels a bit petty, and I hope that we’ll have other players soon join the team who will spice things up and help to support Tom as he rebuilds his government. Virginia Madsen’s other designated survivor could have been a major villain, but she’s proven thus far to be a great ally, and if Googling Tom is the worst she’s done so far, I think he’s safe for now. I worry that the focus on Tom’s children, particularly his obnoxious son, may prove distracting, and I’d prefer to see his wife get more of a spotlight. Maggie Q’s Agent Watts really is this show’s Jack Bauer, the one agent who knows what’s going on who just doesn’t have the benefit of anyone listening to her.
Monday, September 26, 2016
Pilot Review: Designated Survivor
Designated Survivor (ABC)
Premiered September 21 at 10pm
I’m willing to bet that at least 75% of people who watched this pilot did so for one reason alone: star Kiefer Sutherland. The actor carried “24” long past any sense of coherence with a unique ability to remain energetic against any threat that might emerge and be the only one to able to predict where terrorists would strike next. It’s interesting, therefore, that he chose this as his next major project after a brief return to television on FOX’s “Touch.” ABC’s new drama casts Sutherland as a regular guy who likes to spend time at home cooking for his family and acts in the very safe, action-free position of Secretary of Housing and Urban Development. A major attack on the entire Congress and Cabinet makes him, the lowest on the totem pole, the next in line to be President, and suddenly this family man not used to acting under pressure has to lead the country. While Sutherland’s acting could get over the top on “24” (“You have to trust me” was his go-to line), here he’s much more focused and very compelling, exhibiting strength and poise despite discerning and disapproving eyes looking down on him as completely unqualified for the job. Sutherland is ably supported by Maggie Q from “Nikita” as an FBI agent intent on figuring out who attacked the country, Kal Penn as a speech writer, and Natasha McElhone from “Californication” as his loyal wife who still doesn’t think it’s a good idea for him to take on this job. This was a strong pilot, and I imagine this could be one of the more exciting new shows of the season.
How will it work as a series? This opening hour was full of action and intrigue, and this show needs to make sure that it rises above standard political drama to be something more since it’s lost that initial surprise element. The shady conversations happening between conniving underlings to get Sutherland’s Tom booted need to be kept under control, while the continued threat of another attack both should not be underestimated or too much in focus.
How long will it last? This show delivered in a major way with its numbers, all but assuring it a very bright future. Positive reviews don’t hurt either, and as long as this show’s ratings don’t plummet in week two and beyond, this show is guaranteed to be renewed for a second season.
Pilot grade: B+
Premiered September 21 at 10pm
I’m willing to bet that at least 75% of people who watched this pilot did so for one reason alone: star Kiefer Sutherland. The actor carried “24” long past any sense of coherence with a unique ability to remain energetic against any threat that might emerge and be the only one to able to predict where terrorists would strike next. It’s interesting, therefore, that he chose this as his next major project after a brief return to television on FOX’s “Touch.” ABC’s new drama casts Sutherland as a regular guy who likes to spend time at home cooking for his family and acts in the very safe, action-free position of Secretary of Housing and Urban Development. A major attack on the entire Congress and Cabinet makes him, the lowest on the totem pole, the next in line to be President, and suddenly this family man not used to acting under pressure has to lead the country. While Sutherland’s acting could get over the top on “24” (“You have to trust me” was his go-to line), here he’s much more focused and very compelling, exhibiting strength and poise despite discerning and disapproving eyes looking down on him as completely unqualified for the job. Sutherland is ably supported by Maggie Q from “Nikita” as an FBI agent intent on figuring out who attacked the country, Kal Penn as a speech writer, and Natasha McElhone from “Californication” as his loyal wife who still doesn’t think it’s a good idea for him to take on this job. This was a strong pilot, and I imagine this could be one of the more exciting new shows of the season.
How will it work as a series? This opening hour was full of action and intrigue, and this show needs to make sure that it rises above standard political drama to be something more since it’s lost that initial surprise element. The shady conversations happening between conniving underlings to get Sutherland’s Tom booted need to be kept under control, while the continued threat of another attack both should not be underestimated or too much in focus.
How long will it last? This show delivered in a major way with its numbers, all but assuring it a very bright future. Positive reviews don’t hurt either, and as long as this show’s ratings don’t plummet in week two and beyond, this show is guaranteed to be renewed for a second season.
Pilot grade: B+
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
