Valley of Tears: Season 1, Episode 10 “Valley of Tears” (B)
As expected, this series didn’t provide terrible happy endings for its characters. After the tank battle with plenty of casualties, Meni tried desperately to revive Yoni, who was injured and killed. That final post-credits scene was haunting, seeing a wounded Yoni walk through the streets and into a yeshiva where his religious father was studying, what I assume is meant to be an explanation of the impact that finding and then losing his son in this war had on Meni. Melakhi got to engage further with a war that he didn’t seem particularly interested in fighting, nominated to be on the first tank to head to Damascus by Colonel Almogi. He forgave Marco for everything in the heat of the moment because they had survived, an important development in their friendship even if it paled in comparison to everything else that happened on the battlefield. Avinoam was astute in his ability to recognize a spokesman on the radio broadcast he heard about Jerusalem and Tel Aviv having been invaded as Israel was prepared to surrender, but that didn’t stop the interrogator from bringing in Yoav and threatening to kill him if Avinoam didn’t talk. And the only parting glimpse of Dafna that we got was her walking through the desert, not found by the Syrians but also not able to locate either Yoav or Avinoam. This series has certainly been interesting, but it never quite reached the emotional impact of something like “Lebanon” or “Our Boys” to me. I’d still recommend it as an involving portrayal of war and a tribute to the many people who fought in the Yom Kippur War.
Series grade: B+
Series MVP: Shahar Taboch as Avinoam
Showing posts with label Valley of Tears. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Valley of Tears. Show all posts
Friday, December 11, 2020
What I’m Watching: Valley of Tears (Penultimate Episode)
Valley of Tears: Season 1, Episode 9 “The Abyss” (B+)
This episode felt like it jumped around a lot less, focusing in on its various storylines without breaking too much from them. The first few minutes were all about the tank with plenty of pressure and an intensity on the battlefield. The humorous banter between Meni and Melakhi helped produce a useful conclusion, that the Syrians were all about closing their hatches while keeping theirs open could actually provide the unit with an advantage since they would be able to see more clearly. Melakhi’s motivational speech about how the Syrians were on their way to his mother’s home in Jerusalem seemed to rally the assembled troops, and Meni fittingly relinquished command to the man who knew what he wanted and how to convince others that it was right to fight for it. Marco’s confession about trying to save his mother was an important moment that Melakhi seemed to take as best he could, and Meni and Yoni had their own version of a lukewarm father-son exchange that ended more positively than I might have expected. Avinoam and Dafna’s expedition to find Yoav ended in Avinoam’s almost immediate surrender and capture, and I thought that we were going to see him being interrogated at the end of the episode after he tried to talk too much to the other prisoners around him. Instead, we heard an argument made that it was indeed the Israelis and their Zionist imperialist ideals that started this war that began with a surprise attack, and the interrogator didn’t seem all that sincere about their shared culture when he didn’t get the answer he wanted. The finale will surely feature some closure, and I don’t imagine that all of these characters will survive what’s coming.
This episode felt like it jumped around a lot less, focusing in on its various storylines without breaking too much from them. The first few minutes were all about the tank with plenty of pressure and an intensity on the battlefield. The humorous banter between Meni and Melakhi helped produce a useful conclusion, that the Syrians were all about closing their hatches while keeping theirs open could actually provide the unit with an advantage since they would be able to see more clearly. Melakhi’s motivational speech about how the Syrians were on their way to his mother’s home in Jerusalem seemed to rally the assembled troops, and Meni fittingly relinquished command to the man who knew what he wanted and how to convince others that it was right to fight for it. Marco’s confession about trying to save his mother was an important moment that Melakhi seemed to take as best he could, and Meni and Yoni had their own version of a lukewarm father-son exchange that ended more positively than I might have expected. Avinoam and Dafna’s expedition to find Yoav ended in Avinoam’s almost immediate surrender and capture, and I thought that we were going to see him being interrogated at the end of the episode after he tried to talk too much to the other prisoners around him. Instead, we heard an argument made that it was indeed the Israelis and their Zionist imperialist ideals that started this war that began with a surprise attack, and the interrogator didn’t seem all that sincere about their shared culture when he didn’t get the answer he wanted. The finale will surely feature some closure, and I don’t imagine that all of these characters will survive what’s coming.
Friday, December 4, 2020
What I’m Watching: Valley of Tears
Valley of Tears: Season 1, Episode 8 “Preparing for the Big Battle” (B+)
Colonel Almogi’s rallying speech hit home in an important way, recognizing that circumstances were far from ideal and that this couldn’t be a time for mourning but instead for focused unity. It wasn’t a surprise that Yoni wanted to go back into battle, something that Meni was eager to discourage since he had come there specifically to make sure that his son was safe. What I’m not sure I would have predicted – and what speaks to the humorously casual and improvisational nature of Israeli culture in general – was Meni going with him, acting as the tank commander only because that was the lone responsibility that didn’t require any training. What he saw at the end of the episode was indeed intense and left things off on a very serious note after their more low-key and light-hearted expedition. Melakhi also had a heartfelt moment with his sister, begging her to forgive him and then leaning on Dafna as he wrestled with the guilt of abandoning his brother who sacrificed himself so that they could all live and whose fate will certainly not be good. Dafna’s ex also had his own confession, one that was supportive of the feelings she had for another man and a recognition that he would ultimately be good for her, should he survive given the lack of any direct efforts to go and rescue him. It’s good to see Avinoam’s attitude shift to one of defiance after for so long advocating for this conflict’s inevitability and to see how he fiercely he wants to be loyal to Yoav.
Colonel Almogi’s rallying speech hit home in an important way, recognizing that circumstances were far from ideal and that this couldn’t be a time for mourning but instead for focused unity. It wasn’t a surprise that Yoni wanted to go back into battle, something that Meni was eager to discourage since he had come there specifically to make sure that his son was safe. What I’m not sure I would have predicted – and what speaks to the humorously casual and improvisational nature of Israeli culture in general – was Meni going with him, acting as the tank commander only because that was the lone responsibility that didn’t require any training. What he saw at the end of the episode was indeed intense and left things off on a very serious note after their more low-key and light-hearted expedition. Melakhi also had a heartfelt moment with his sister, begging her to forgive him and then leaning on Dafna as he wrestled with the guilt of abandoning his brother who sacrificed himself so that they could all live and whose fate will certainly not be good. Dafna’s ex also had his own confession, one that was supportive of the feelings she had for another man and a recognition that he would ultimately be good for her, should he survive given the lack of any direct efforts to go and rescue him. It’s good to see Avinoam’s attitude shift to one of defiance after for so long advocating for this conflict’s inevitability and to see how he fiercely he wants to be loyal to Yoav.
What I’m Watching: Valley of Tears
Valley of Tears: Season 1, Episode 7 “Night at the Bunker” (B+)
All of the characters are so close to each other geographically, yet there are so many barriers that keep them apart and make it so that all of them won’t be able to survive. The realization that Caspi couldn’t hear and that he needed to see the reason to stop calling out over and over for water was important, and one soldier managed to save them all by going out to the Syrians and declaring that he was the lone survivor of a company of four. Meni’s ability to jump onto whatever channel he wanted and gain incredible access to equipment and vehicles was subverted slightly when he was convinced that, without night vision, he would be hopeless to rescue his son, and he managed to get to him the next morning with the entire troop. I don’t know what happens next since Meni would be liable to be arrested if everyone wasn’t so concerned with staying focused and fighting the war, and Yoni likely won’t want to just abandon his fellow soldiers even if his father’s first priority is evacuating him to safety. Dafna was so close to finding out about Yoav’s fate, but Avinoam wasn’t conscious when she came to see him and was disappointed, and simultaneously relieved, to learn that it wasn’t Yoav. Avinoam was not happy to hear that he was being accused of treason for failing to destroy documents when his life was in jeopardy, and I suspect that, especially after being threatened with imprisonment, he’s going to do whatever he can to save Yoav.
All of the characters are so close to each other geographically, yet there are so many barriers that keep them apart and make it so that all of them won’t be able to survive. The realization that Caspi couldn’t hear and that he needed to see the reason to stop calling out over and over for water was important, and one soldier managed to save them all by going out to the Syrians and declaring that he was the lone survivor of a company of four. Meni’s ability to jump onto whatever channel he wanted and gain incredible access to equipment and vehicles was subverted slightly when he was convinced that, without night vision, he would be hopeless to rescue his son, and he managed to get to him the next morning with the entire troop. I don’t know what happens next since Meni would be liable to be arrested if everyone wasn’t so concerned with staying focused and fighting the war, and Yoni likely won’t want to just abandon his fellow soldiers even if his father’s first priority is evacuating him to safety. Dafna was so close to finding out about Yoav’s fate, but Avinoam wasn’t conscious when she came to see him and was disappointed, and simultaneously relieved, to learn that it wasn’t Yoav. Avinoam was not happy to hear that he was being accused of treason for failing to destroy documents when his life was in jeopardy, and I suspect that, especially after being threatened with imprisonment, he’s going to do whatever he can to save Yoav.
Friday, November 27, 2020
What I’m Watching: Valley of Tears
Valley of Tears: Season 1, Episode 6 “Rain on Us!” (B+)
Things don’t seem to be all that secure at HQ, better known as Tokyo, since Meni was able to just walk around, pick up a phone, and pose as a mysterious commander to give one unit an order to go pick up his son while no one was paying attention. We got to see more of the colonel played by Ohad Knoller, who I first encountered in his early roles in “The Bubble” and “Beaufort,” who was laying out the reality of the situation and seemed impressed by Dafna’s ability to focus on what was important even without the proper resources being available. She understands that, despite her desire to find Yoav, the safety and security of the entire military comes before one person since everyone deserves to be rescued. The group out on the hill managed to survive pretty well with the fire ordered by Caspi, but going back out to get the radio put them all at significant risk. Melahki was so casual and annoying on the radio with Dafna when he realized that Yoni was in his presence, and it was likely heartbreaking for Meni to hear that his son was alive and well but unwilling to speak to him. After Yoav got him through the minefield, Avinoam stepped up to save him, tying a tourniquet and dragging him an incredible distance. He wasn’t at all okay with the idea of shooting Yoav, and even worried about leaving a gun with him because he might do it himself. Survival doesn’t seem likely for either of them at this point, but I think they can prevail.
Things don’t seem to be all that secure at HQ, better known as Tokyo, since Meni was able to just walk around, pick up a phone, and pose as a mysterious commander to give one unit an order to go pick up his son while no one was paying attention. We got to see more of the colonel played by Ohad Knoller, who I first encountered in his early roles in “The Bubble” and “Beaufort,” who was laying out the reality of the situation and seemed impressed by Dafna’s ability to focus on what was important even without the proper resources being available. She understands that, despite her desire to find Yoav, the safety and security of the entire military comes before one person since everyone deserves to be rescued. The group out on the hill managed to survive pretty well with the fire ordered by Caspi, but going back out to get the radio put them all at significant risk. Melahki was so casual and annoying on the radio with Dafna when he realized that Yoni was in his presence, and it was likely heartbreaking for Meni to hear that his son was alive and well but unwilling to speak to him. After Yoav got him through the minefield, Avinoam stepped up to save him, tying a tourniquet and dragging him an incredible distance. He wasn’t at all okay with the idea of shooting Yoav, and even worried about leaving a gun with him because he might do it himself. Survival doesn’t seem likely for either of them at this point, but I think they can prevail.
What I’m Watching: Valley of Tears
Valley of Tears: Season 1, Episode 5 “Stuck on the Hill” (B+)
Things are definitely serious now, with the joyride ended as Meni gave Melakhi some important advice about not trusting people – a notion he shouldn’t employ right now – before he went off to rejoin and rescue his friends. Telling the base that the pilot was still alive was a clever way to get help sent, but they ultimately decided to stay and defend the hill rather than go back and retreat. Hearing that the Syrians were at the Sea of Galilee was devastating news, and it’s becoming clearer and clearer that this is not an ordinary conflict. Dafna continues to remain calm under pressure, getting reserve drivers on the way so that they can be of help. It was strange to hear all about her from Yoav as he talked Avinoam down and kept him focused as they were navigating their way through the minefield. It was good to see Yoav acknowledge Avinoam’s skills and actually ask about him, and Avinoam gave him some decent advice about how to move forward with Dafna given the strong feelings he had towards her. While he did manage to get Avinoam through without incident, it was in a quiet moment immediately afterwards that Yoav set off a mine that appears to have killed him, which is going to strand Avinoam in the desert far from anyone else all by himself. He did fine when he came upon the Syrian soldier who Yoav then shot, but Avinoam could really use a friend to help him survive this.
Things are definitely serious now, with the joyride ended as Meni gave Melakhi some important advice about not trusting people – a notion he shouldn’t employ right now – before he went off to rejoin and rescue his friends. Telling the base that the pilot was still alive was a clever way to get help sent, but they ultimately decided to stay and defend the hill rather than go back and retreat. Hearing that the Syrians were at the Sea of Galilee was devastating news, and it’s becoming clearer and clearer that this is not an ordinary conflict. Dafna continues to remain calm under pressure, getting reserve drivers on the way so that they can be of help. It was strange to hear all about her from Yoav as he talked Avinoam down and kept him focused as they were navigating their way through the minefield. It was good to see Yoav acknowledge Avinoam’s skills and actually ask about him, and Avinoam gave him some decent advice about how to move forward with Dafna given the strong feelings he had towards her. While he did manage to get Avinoam through without incident, it was in a quiet moment immediately afterwards that Yoav set off a mine that appears to have killed him, which is going to strand Avinoam in the desert far from anyone else all by himself. He did fine when he came upon the Syrian soldier who Yoav then shot, but Avinoam could really use a friend to help him survive this.
Thursday, November 19, 2020
What I’m Watching: Valley of Tears
Valley of Tears: Season 1, Episode 4 (B+)
After they both experienced shock at the end of the previous episode, both Melakhi and Meni rallied to deal with the chaotic bureaucracy they encountered when they went in to ask questions about those important to them. Dafna wasn’t pleased to learn that there wasn’t help available and that she couldn’t get an answer about how Yoav was doing. On the battlefield, there was such joy that the exposed soldiers felt upon realizing that the plane was above them was friendly which was almost instantly taken away when it got down. Rallying to save the pilot was an affirming, and they’re definitely not out of harm’s way even though they managed to take out the Syrians who nearly got the ejected pilot back to their Jeep. Avinoam’s encounter with a Syrian soldier who just wanted water and even invited him to come visit in Damascus if they ever achieved peace was a poignant moment, but also one that was quickly replaced by a sense of dread that this kind of exchange was fleeting and unrealistic. There’s a good deal of discord between the strongest personalities who are facing difficult circumstances, and Caspi once again seemed like he was making reckless decisions that were going to get the rest of the unit killed. We also got confirmation on the identity of the shell-shocked soldier who has now snapped back to reality, and Yoni is now fully embroiled in everything that’s going on after being confronted with a life-or-death situation in which he reacted and saved the life of the pilot by shooting the Syrian soldier.
After they both experienced shock at the end of the previous episode, both Melakhi and Meni rallied to deal with the chaotic bureaucracy they encountered when they went in to ask questions about those important to them. Dafna wasn’t pleased to learn that there wasn’t help available and that she couldn’t get an answer about how Yoav was doing. On the battlefield, there was such joy that the exposed soldiers felt upon realizing that the plane was above them was friendly which was almost instantly taken away when it got down. Rallying to save the pilot was an affirming, and they’re definitely not out of harm’s way even though they managed to take out the Syrians who nearly got the ejected pilot back to their Jeep. Avinoam’s encounter with a Syrian soldier who just wanted water and even invited him to come visit in Damascus if they ever achieved peace was a poignant moment, but also one that was quickly replaced by a sense of dread that this kind of exchange was fleeting and unrealistic. There’s a good deal of discord between the strongest personalities who are facing difficult circumstances, and Caspi once again seemed like he was making reckless decisions that were going to get the rest of the unit killed. We also got confirmation on the identity of the shell-shocked soldier who has now snapped back to reality, and Yoni is now fully embroiled in everything that’s going on after being confronted with a life-or-death situation in which he reacted and saved the life of the pilot by shooting the Syrian soldier.
Take Three: Valley of Tears
Valley of Tears: Season 1, Episode 3 (B+)
There’s a stark difference in tone between the scenes featuring Melakhi, Meni, and Dafna having the time of their lives driving through checkpoints to music and the ones with Yoav and those in the tanks fighting to stay alive. The ending of the episode did serve to transition the three less serious elements into what’s truly going on, as both Melakhi and Meni began falling apart when they thought they had confirmed their loved ones for dead. Dafna kept a cool and level head, walking around to get the names of those who had died, though she likely would have been more upset if she had encountered what she thought to be her boyfriend. Yoav was doing a good job of keeping the troops united as they tried to descend to the lower levels in order to escape, and it wasn’t an easy task given the nearness of the Syrians who were casually executing their hostages. The idea of going further down into a base is far from comforting, but Avinoam seems sure that it leads to a way out, and given that they’re not sufficiently prepared to fight, retreat is the best option. That’s not the attitude expressed by Caspi, who is insistent on standing his ground and keeping his soldiers with him, despite the very clear confirmation that Israel no longer controls the area where they are and there aren’t going to be reinforcements coming to help them. Perhaps a cool car and its passionate passengers will be just what they need to rally some enthusiasm for a plan that’s otherwise not supported by Caspi’s concerned men.
There’s a stark difference in tone between the scenes featuring Melakhi, Meni, and Dafna having the time of their lives driving through checkpoints to music and the ones with Yoav and those in the tanks fighting to stay alive. The ending of the episode did serve to transition the three less serious elements into what’s truly going on, as both Melakhi and Meni began falling apart when they thought they had confirmed their loved ones for dead. Dafna kept a cool and level head, walking around to get the names of those who had died, though she likely would have been more upset if she had encountered what she thought to be her boyfriend. Yoav was doing a good job of keeping the troops united as they tried to descend to the lower levels in order to escape, and it wasn’t an easy task given the nearness of the Syrians who were casually executing their hostages. The idea of going further down into a base is far from comforting, but Avinoam seems sure that it leads to a way out, and given that they’re not sufficiently prepared to fight, retreat is the best option. That’s not the attitude expressed by Caspi, who is insistent on standing his ground and keeping his soldiers with him, despite the very clear confirmation that Israel no longer controls the area where they are and there aren’t going to be reinforcements coming to help them. Perhaps a cool car and its passionate passengers will be just what they need to rally some enthusiasm for a plan that’s otherwise not supported by Caspi’s concerned men.
Saturday, November 14, 2020
Round Two: Valley of Tears
Valley of Tears: Season 1, Episode 2 (B+)
This show really seems to fluctuate between the intensity of battle when the soldiers are suddenly under attack and a more casual attitude expressed by those who haven’t yet accepted the reality of what’s going on around them. The best example is Lior Ashkenazi’s Menny, who just wants to drive his nice car up to try to find his son and is happy to eat the food that his unexpected passenger has brought despite the fact that it’s Yom Kippur. It was jarring to see the nonchalant way in which the commanders told the soldiers to eat the fruit and vegetables that they had stockpiled to break their fast so that they would be ready even without a confirmed idea of what the engagement was going to be. Avinoam has been panicking since the first scene of the previous episode, and it’s clear that, even though his intelligence is good, his attitude isn’t too helpful. Yoav coming back to save him after locking him in resulted in a complicated reaction from Avinoam, whose knowledge of the base and the ways to either hide or escape it are going to be extremely crucial to everyone’s survival. It’s also clear that Dafna isn’t going to be told that she needs to leave just because she’s a woman, and she’s intent on having a more active role in whatever is to come. The final moment of this episode and the one before it was powerful, and the inclusion of real footage is a nice touch. I’ll look forward to watching the next two episodes when they premiere this coming Thursday.
This show really seems to fluctuate between the intensity of battle when the soldiers are suddenly under attack and a more casual attitude expressed by those who haven’t yet accepted the reality of what’s going on around them. The best example is Lior Ashkenazi’s Menny, who just wants to drive his nice car up to try to find his son and is happy to eat the food that his unexpected passenger has brought despite the fact that it’s Yom Kippur. It was jarring to see the nonchalant way in which the commanders told the soldiers to eat the fruit and vegetables that they had stockpiled to break their fast so that they would be ready even without a confirmed idea of what the engagement was going to be. Avinoam has been panicking since the first scene of the previous episode, and it’s clear that, even though his intelligence is good, his attitude isn’t too helpful. Yoav coming back to save him after locking him in resulted in a complicated reaction from Avinoam, whose knowledge of the base and the ways to either hide or escape it are going to be extremely crucial to everyone’s survival. It’s also clear that Dafna isn’t going to be told that she needs to leave just because she’s a woman, and she’s intent on having a more active role in whatever is to come. The final moment of this episode and the one before it was powerful, and the inclusion of real footage is a nice touch. I’ll look forward to watching the next two episodes when they premiere this coming Thursday.
Pilot Review: Valley of Tears
Check out my one-minute take on every new pilot, which is embedded below and you can also watch by subscribing to movieswithabe on YouTube.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



